SpineUniverse Community Advice
Get help and share your story with others who know what you're going through.
Please register or log in to join the discussions!

PA unreal. Soon this will be the norm.

Started by ragweed2011 on 10/03/2013 11:18am

The Pennsylvania Medical Society is threatening to pull its support for a proposed statewide prescription drug monitoring effort over an amendment that would automatically alert police every time a patient is ordered to take certain drugs.
The bill could violate federal patient privacy laws, said C. Richard Schott, a Delaware County cardiologist, president of the Pennsylvania Medical Society.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania first raised the alarm about patient privacy in the drug monitoring database. Andrew Hoover, legislative director of the ACLU in Pennsylvania, said the organization agrees with the medical society.
Pennsylvania has an existing database that provides the Attorney General’s Office with information about prescriptions for extremely addictive drugs. The proposed expansion would allow doctors to access the database and add a number of other prescription drugs that are being increasingly abused. Proponents of the database say it’s needed to stem the tide of overdoses from prescription drug abuse by recreational users and addicts.
The medical society had been actively lobbying in favor of the database because it would make it easier for doctors to recognize “pill-shoppers,” people faking ailments to get drugs.
A new amendment would propose a computer-generated “automatic notification” provided to the Attorney General’s Office, with sharing provisions to local district attorneys for irregular or illegal patterns of activity involving prescription drugs. This is not substantially different from the way the existing database works. But that database only includes extremely addictive drugs, such as cocaine and heroin and chemically similar alternatives.
The expanded program would add a host of drugs, including steroids, anti-anxiety medication and some forms of cold medication.
The original expanded drug monitoring plan would have required a court order for police to access patient information, said Schott. That was weakened so police could get the information about an “active investigation.” Doctors were willing to accept that compromise, but the latest changes weaken the privacy protections even further.
Schott imagined the worst case scenario: An elderly patient in hospice receiving heavy doses of painkillers to cope with the end of life. He concedes it’s unlikely that police would intentionally want to bother a person who is receiving medication for legitimate need. But the weakened standards for police access create the danger that officers could unintentionally bother law-abiding patients.
Doctors also fear that patients will stop seeking medical care if they fear that police will receive notifications about what types of drugs they are being prescribed.
Schott said Pennsylvania needs drug monitoring, in part, because neighboring states have such monitoring programs.
“If you’re a burglar, you go to a gun-free zone, if you are drug-shopper, you go to where there is no drug monitoring,” Schott said.
But, if the patient-privacy concerns are not dealt with, the medical society will not support the legislation, he said.

Do you find this discussion helpful?

3 Responses


Hi Ray,how are you doing?Sorry i have been off here for awhile.I hate feeling like the victim in a seemingly endless cycle of surgery-pain-social security-denials-doctors-etc..etc...anyway get the picture?Anyhow we are all in the same boat in one way or another so i just pray every day that God will help me make the most of residual functioning capacity in a jacked up spine that will never be the same again.Trying to be grateful for the small things.If you want to read my full update i just posted a whole paragraph.Oh BTW,did you win SS yet?I just need a little hope and prayers.Today i don't even have a dollar in my checking account......and this is no joke!
Take Care.
Nancy Nurse


Sorry about my post.
Just going threw the waves of this crazy life.
It's finally snowing today.
I'm happy to see it :)


This is absolutely incredible. What is next? I feel like we are being drawn more and more into a big brother nation. This is a blatant violation of patient rights. I'm sure there are ways of flagging drug shopping without flagging every person on these meds. I'm glad we don't live in PA anymore although I'm sure this legislation is not far from being instituted in more states than just PA.

Please keep us posted.