|
** OUTCOMES OF POSTERIOR
DECOMPRESSION AND FUSION WITH AND WITHOUT INSTRUMENTATION FOR LUMBAR SPINAL
STENOSIS WITH DEFORMITY: AN INNER CITY TEACHING INSTITUTION RETROSPECTIVE
STUDY
John M. Olsewski, MD;
Edouard F. Armour, MD;
Hilary Umans, MD
Bronx, New York, USA
55 consecutive patients of the same surgeon and same institution with
lumbar spinal stenosis and spine deformity (spondylolisthesis. retrolisthesis,
scoliosis) treated surgically with both decompression and fusion were
retrospectively reviewed for the affect of instrumentation on surgical
and clinical results. Group I consisted of 33 patients (18 male, 15 female)
with a mean age of 53.4 years, all of whom had pedicle screw fixation
as an adjunct to their fusions. Group II consisted of 22 patients (11
male, 11 female) with a mean age of 62.3 years, and had no internal fixation
along with their fusions. Minimum followup was 24 months with a mean
of 40.4 +/ 14.1 months for Group I and a mean of 33.6 +/ 8.2 months
for Group II. All patients had failed a minimum of six months of nonoperative
treatment (physical therapy, NSAID'S, epidural steroids), with a mean
time to surgical intervention of 9.1 months. Medical comorbidities averaged
1.1 for Group I and 1.3 for Group II. Evidence of arthrodesis or pseudoarthrosis
was graded blindly by an independent bone radiologist. Patient satisfaction
for both preoperative and postoperative leg pain as well as back pain
was graded via visual analog scale. Statistical analysis was via Student's
ttest. Group I had a mean improvement in leg pain postoperatively of
52.3% (8.8 to 4.2, p < 0.05), and a mean improvement in back pain of 47.8%
(9.0 to 4.7, p < 0.05). The pseudoarthrosis rate in Group I was 15.2%
(5/33). Group II had a mean improvement in leg pain postoperatively of
67.1% (7.9 to 2.6, p < 0.05), and a mean improvement in back pain of 59.2%
(8.1 to 3.3, p < 0.05). The pseudoarthrosis rate in Group II was 22.7%
(5/22). Complications in Group I were 24% and included 2 wound seromas,
2 deep wound infections, 2 dural tears, one transient nerve root deficit
and 1 failed hardware. Complications in Group II were 14% and included
2 dural tears and 1 deep wound infection. Group I mean age was statistically
younger (p < 0.05) than Group II. There was a correlation between pseudoarthrosis
and less satisfactory results in Group I (p<0.05), but not in Group II.
There was no correlation between results and Workman's Compensation status.
There were no correlations between comorbidities, including smoking, and
pseudoarthrosis or unsatisfactory result rates. Instrumentation improved
fusion rate in patients undergoing decompression and fusion for spinal
stenosis with deformity, but had no statistical affect on clinical results.
There was a trend towards a higher complication rate in the instrumented
group, especially with regards to wound complications.
** The FDA has not cleared a drug and/or medical device
for the use described in this presentation. (i.e., the drug or medical
device is being discussed in an “offlabel: use).
|
|